Chaga vs Reishi: Which Mushroom for Which Job

Articles

Functional Mushrooms

Chaga growing on a birch trunk beside a glossy reishi mushroom on a mossy log in warm forest light

Functional Mushrooms · Comparison

Chaga or reishi? They’re two of the oldest functional mushrooms, and they’re used for very different goals.

Chaga vs reishi comes up often for anyone starting with functional mushrooms. Both are sold as extracts, and both often sit side by side on the shelf. One grows on birch trees in cold northern forests, the other on hardwood logs in warmer ones, and each carries its own mix of natural compounds. Knowing what sets them apart makes it easier to pick the one that fits your goal.

Below, we’ll look at what each mushroom is, what’s inside it, what research has looked at, and which goal each one suits.

Key Terms

Functional mushroom: a mushroom used to support health rather than eaten as food.
Extract ratio: how much dried mushroom goes into the finished extract. 8:1 means eight parts of mushroom make one part of extract.
Beta-glucans: chains of natural sugars in mushroom cell walls that the immune system can recognize.
Triterpenes: natural compounds that give some mushrooms, especially reishi, their bitter taste.

What is chaga?

Chaga (Inonotus obliquus) grows on birch trees in the cold northern forests of Finland, Russia, Canada and the northern United States. From a distance it looks like a lump of burnt charcoal on the bark. Break it open, and the inside is a soft, rusty orange.

For centuries, people in Russia and Northern Europe brewed chaga as a daily tea, especially through long winters, as a tonic for strength and stamina. Today, most chaga is sold as an extract, which concentrates its compounds into a small amount of powder.

What’s inside chaga?

Chaga’s dark color comes from melanin-type pigments. It also carries polyphenols, the plant compounds that give tea and berries their color, along with triterpenes and some beta-glucans.

A lab study of chaga from three countries1 measured these compounds and found strong antioxidant activity in the extracts. Antioxidants help the body handle oxidative stress, the everyday wear on cells from normal living. The amounts varied from one sample to the next, which is why where chaga comes from and how it’s extracted both matter.

What is reishi?

Reishi (Ganoderma lucidum) grows on old hardwood logs and stumps, often oak. It looks like a glossy, red-brown fan that has been painted with varnish. In China it’s called lingzhi, and it has been used in East Asia for more than two thousand years as a calming tonic for a long, steady life.

Reishi is tough, woody and very bitter, so it’s almost always taken as an extract. Hot water draws out its beta-glucans, and alcohol draws out its triterpenes. Extracts made with both steps, called dual extracts, capture both groups.

What research has looked at for reishi

In an eight-week study in older women2, one group took a dry reishi extract and another took a look-alike placebo, with neither the women nor the researchers knowing who had which. Researchers then tested how the women’s T cells, white blood cells that help coordinate immune responses, behaved. The reishi group’s T cells responded differently from the placebo group’s, a sign that reishi interacts with the immune system.

Reishi’s beta-glucans are a big part of why it’s linked with immune support.

Chaga vs reishi: the key differences

How chaga and reishi compare

Chaga and reishi

QuestionChagaReishi
Where it growsBirch trees in cold northern forestsHardwood logs, often oak
Part usedThe dense, dark growth on the barkThe glossy shelf (fruiting body)
Best-known compoundsDark pigments, polyphenols, triterpenesBeta-glucans and bitter triterpenes
Traditional useA daily tonic for strength and staminaA calming tonic for a long, steady life
Often chosen forSteady daily energyImmune support
TasteEarthy and mildVery bitter

Neither one is better overall; the choice comes down to your goal. Many people take both, in separate formulas for separate goals, and a practitioner can help you decide what fits.

MycoRev Tonic: chaga in a daily formula

If chaga is your pick, MycoRev Tonic from 3rd Planet, which Aduco carries, pairs it with cordyceps and lion’s mane. It’s made to support steady energy, healthy immune function and clear, focused thinking.* Each capsule contains:

MycoRev Tonic Supplement Facts, per serving (1 capsule)

MycoRev Tonic label

IngredientMade fromAmount per serving
Chaga 8:1 organic sclerotium extractInonotus obliquus sclerotium 1.6 g200 mg
Cordyceps 8:1 organic fruitbody extractCordyceps militaris organic fruitbody 750 mg75 mg
Lion’s Mane 8:1 organic fruitbody extractHericium erinaceus organic fruitbody 1.0 g125 mg

The chaga is dual-extracted with alcohol and water, so both its water-soluble and fat-soluble compounds come through, and each batch is tested for beta-glucan content. For more on the formula, see What Makes MycoRev Tonic Different.

MycoRev Immune: reishi with shiitake and maitake

If reishi is your pick, MycoRev Immune from 3rd Planet, which Aduco carries, combines it with shiitake and maitake for immune support.* Each capsule contains:

MycoRev Immune Supplement Facts, per serving (1 capsule)

MycoRev Immune label

IngredientMade fromAmount per serving
Reishi 16:1 organic fruitbody extractGanoderma lucidum organic fruitbody 1.44 g90 mg
Shiitake 8:1 organic fruitbody extractLentinula edodes organic fruitbody 1.6 g200 mg
Maitake 8:1 organic fruitbody extractGrifola frondosa organic fruitbody 1.1 g110 mg

The reishi is the most concentrated extract in the capsule, at 16:1. It’s dual-extracted with alcohol and water to capture both groups of compounds, and it’s tested to contain at least 15% beta-glucans and 4% triterpenes. For more on the formula, see What Makes MycoRev Immune Different, or read The Role of Mushrooms in Immunomodulation.

Available at Aduco

3rd Planet functional mushrooms

MycoRev Tonic for chaga, MycoRev Immune for reishi.

Frequently asked questions

QIs chaga or reishi better?
Neither is better overall. Chaga is usually chosen for steady daily energy, and reishi for immune support. Pick the one that matches your goal.
QCan you take chaga and reishi together?
Many people do, often in separate formulas for separate goals. Ask your practitioner whether both fit your health and anything else you take.
QWhy is reishi so bitter?
Its bitterness comes from triterpenes, a group of natural compounds. That’s why reishi is almost always taken as an extract rather than eaten.
QWhat does 16:1 mean on a reishi label?
It’s the extract ratio: sixteen parts of dried reishi went into one part of finished extract. In MycoRev Immune, 90 mg of extract comes from 1.44 g of reishi.
QWhat is a dual extract?
An extract made with both hot water and alcohol. Water draws out beta-glucans, and alcohol draws out triterpenes, so a dual extract captures both.
QWhich 3rd Planet formulas contain chaga and reishi?
MycoRev Tonic contains chaga, with cordyceps and lion’s mane. MycoRev Immune contains reishi, with shiitake and maitake.

Sources

  1. 1
    Laboratory study 2015

    Glamočlija J, Ćirić A, Nikolić M, et al. (2015). Chemical characterization and biological activity of Chaga (Inonotus obliquus), a medicinal "mushroom". Journal of ethnopharmacology.

  2. 2
    Randomized controlled trial 2024

    Iser-Bem PN, Lobato TB, Alecrim-Zeza AL, et al. (2024). Ganoderma lucidum dry extract supplementation modulates T lymphocyte function in older women. The British journal of nutrition.